Yes, you might be able to. Under New York General Business Law §349, you can sue a company for deceptive practices that are consumer-oriented, misleading, and cause you injury. If the finance company misrepresented that a late payment extension wouldn’t affect your next due date and then repossessed your car, this could potentially be a deceptive practice. The Kugel Law Firm can help you assess your situation and determine if you have a valid claim.